Salem From Sabrina: Who Voiced and Played Him, and What Breed?
Nick Bakay voiced Salem on Sabrina the Teenage Witch (1996 to 2003).6 For the first four seasons he performed the lines live just off the set.24 Animatronic puppets and trained cats did the acting.4 For breed, Archie Comics, which introduced Salem in 1962, calls him "Sabrina Spellman's American shorthair cat," though it says early comics drew him as an orange tabby.1
- Breed
- American Shorthair, according to Archie Comics1
- Sex
- Male, a former warlock1
- Coat
- Black in the 1996 TV movie and the sitcom;31 an orange tabby in early comics, Archie says1
- First appearance
- Archie's Mad House #22, 19621
- Creator
- Archie Comics; his 1962 debut story was written by George Gladir and drawn by Dan DeCarlo8
- Owner
- Sabrina Spellman; he lives with her and her aunts Hilda and Zelda1
- Voiced by
- Nick Bakay on the sitcom;2 Luke Cook in season 4 of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina5
- Played by
- Animatronic puppets and trained cats, among them Elvis, Lucy, Witch and Salem4
Who voiced Salem?
Nick Bakay, hired as a sitcom writer while he was voicing Norbert on The Angry Beavers. "It was an inside job," he said.2 When the cat was in a scene, he left the writers' room and did the voice live under a boom mic while head puppeteer Thom Fountain worked the mouth.2 For the last three seasons, after Bakay left to write for The King of Queens, he dubbed the lines in a studio.4
Which cats and puppets played Salem?
Both, and one episode could mix a live cat, an animatronic puppet and a stuffed cat.4 Bakay counts "five or six at least" puppets from two puppet-building operations, and says ABC was "not a big fan of the puppet" in season 1, so the live cat got more screen time.2 Animal fabricator Jim Boulden built the first-season Salem from foam rubber and rabbit fur.4
| Performer | What it did |
|---|---|
| Witch | Many of the stunts4 |
| Elvis | Scenes where Salem had to stay put4 |
| Salem, a cat of that name | Scenes that called for "more unpredictable energy"4 |
| Lucy | Named with the other three in a 1997 Los Angeles Times story4 |
| Two main animatronics | One sitting, one lying down, run by Thom Fountain (mouth), Jim Greenall (ears and tail, by remote control) and Mauri Bernstein (head and body, hidden on set)4 |
| "Stuffy" | Stuffed stand-ins for rehearsals and quick shots of Salem flying past the camera4 |
Trainer Mark Watters said the cats learned their actions through food rewards.4
Who played Salem in the 1996 TV movie?
A trained cat that American Humane's report does not name. Bakay calls that film "a movie version of it for Showtime,"2 and American Humane dates it April 12, 1996,3 months before the sitcom premiered on September 27.4 The cat and a white poodle trained together to a buzzer, and the cat's change into mice was done by computer. American Humane was not on set for the Canadian production, but after conferring with the producers it rated the film "Acceptable."3
What breed is Salem?
An American Shorthair, says his publisher: Archie Comics calls him "Sabrina Spellman's American shorthair cat."1 None of the sources I opened on the sitcom's cats names their breed. Solid black is an accepted American Shorthair color, and the Cat Fanciers' Association standard asks for "dense coal black, sound from roots to tip of fur."7 The black cat facts page covers the color.
Mix-ups and myths
"Salem was always black." Wrong. Archie says early comics showed "an orange-colored tabby who does not speak," and the sitcom's success gave him black fur and a voice.1 One review of the 1962 debut story does describe "a little black cat familiar named Salem."8 Tabby is a pattern, not a breed.
"The Hocus Pocus puppet became Salem." Unconfirmed. Screen Rant, citing WhatCulture, says the sitcom reused the film's animatronic cat,9 but the named builders differ: Tony Gardner made the Binx puppet,10 Jim Boulden the first-season Salem.4
"The Netflix Salem never talks." He is mute for much of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, and Screen Rant says he took a back seat because star Kiernan Shipka is allergic to cats. In season 4 he talks again, voiced by Luke Cook.5
Salem quiz: 5 questions
In which comic did Salem first appear?
Answer
Archie's Mad House #22, in 1962.1
What color was Salem in early comics, according to Archie Comics?
Answer
Orange. An orange tabby who did not speak.1
Which cartoon character was Nick Bakay voicing when he got the part?
Answer
Norbert, on The Angry Beavers.2
On the sitcom, how long was Salem sentenced to live as a cat?
Answer
100 years.2
Which of the sitcom's cats handled many of the stunts?
Answer
Witch.4
More cat questions are waiting in the Cat Trivia game, free to play with no account.
Frequently asked questions
Is Salem a boy or a girl?
A boy. Archie writes of "his now-trademark black fur," and its 2009 spin-off Young Salem went back to when he was "an actual boy warlock."1
Why was Salem turned into a cat?
The Witches' Council punished him for plotting to take over the world, according to Archie.1 On the sitcom the sentence was 100 years.2
Where are the Salem puppets now?
One is in the permanent collection of the Center for Puppetry Arts in Atlanta, and a sitting puppet sold at Heritage Auctions for $4,875 in October 2023.4
References
- Archie Comics (2018). Salem Saberhagen: character page. back
- Kathryn Lindsay, Refinery29 (October 18, 2018). The voice of the original Salem has some thoughts about Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (interview with Nick Bakay). back
- American Humane. Sabrina the Teenage Witch (1996 film): certified production, detailed animal action report. back
- Lauren Novak, Remind Magazine (September 27, 2026). 7 fun facts about Salem the cat from Sabrina the Teenage Witch, and where is he now? Summarizes a 1997 Los Angeles Times story and a 2019 Vanity Fair article. back
- Cathal Gunning, Screen Rant (January 4, 2021). Chilling Adventures of Sabrina: who voices Salem the talking cat. back
- Marykate Jasper, The Mary Sue (February 10, 2018). Things we saw today: The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina shows off its Salem. back
- Cat Fanciers' Association. American Shorthair: about the breed and breed standard. back
- J. Caleb Mozzocco, Good Comics for Kids, School Library Journal (July 12, 2017). Review: The Complete Sabrina the Teenage Witch Vol. 1: 1962-1972. back
- Antonella Gugliersi, Screen Rant (October 18, 2023). Hocus Pocus' Thackery Binx secretly appeared in a '90s horror show. back
- Gloss Angeles podcast, episode 90 (October 30, 2020). Hocus Pocus behind-the-scenes stories with SFX makeup artist Tony Gardner. back
Written by Christopher Fox under our editorial policy.


