Church in Pet Sematary: What Breed Is He, and Who Played Him?

Share

Stephen King's own site gives Church no breed, listing him only as Winston Churchill, the Creeds' "5 year-old cat."1 The films chose their own cats. SlashFilm calls the 1989 Church a British shorthair,5 and the 2019 remake used Maine Coon-type shelter cats, four of them credited: Tonic, Leo, JD and Jaeger, Inverse reports.4

Breed
No breed stated by King's site;1 2019 co-director Dennis Widmyer calls the book's Church "a very basic cat"5
Full name
Winston Churchill, Church for short1
Sex
Male91
Coat
On screen, "smokey gray" in 1989, per Cinema Cats,11 and long-haired in 2019, per Widmyer5
First appearance
The novel Pet Sematary, published by Doubleday in November 19831
Creator
Stephen King1
Owner
The Creed family: Louis, Rachel, Ellie and Gage9
Played by
1989: "eight or nine cats," per director Mary Lambert;6 2019: Tonic, Leo, JD and Jaeger4
Inspired by
Smucky, the King family's cat, hit by a truck9

What breed is Church?

No breed is given for the book's Church in King's character list,1 and Widmyer, who directed the 2019 film with Kevin Kölsch, said "in the book, it's a very basic cat."5 The Doubleday hardcover shows "the face of a demonic, green-eyed cat," Caroline Bicks writes in Lit Hub.9

For 1989, SlashFilm calls Lambert's Church a British shorthair,5 though no 1989 production source I found names one. For 2019, Widmyer said they went back to the hardcover and decided "it's like a Maine Coon, with, like, four exotic colors and long hair."5 He told American Humane they based the look on "the original drawing of Church from the first hardcover edition."2

Which cats played Church?

Director Mary Lambert used "eight or nine cats" for Paramount's 1989 film, released April 21 that year,3 picking a cat for each action because "cats really cannot be trained to do multiple things," she told The Hollywood Reporter, as quoted by Far Out.6 For one shot of Church being put to sleep she wanted the cat "dopey," and "after much discussion and negotiation, we gave the cat a sedative."6

Paramount's remake opened on April 5, 2019, with American Humane safety representatives on set.2 Animal coordinator Kirk Jarrett and trainer Melissa Millett recruited five shelter cats; one proved "too timid" and was rehomed.4

Cats who played Church in Pet Sematary (2019)
CatRoleNotes
TonicThe living Church10 months old, the trainers' best "action cat"4
JaegerBackup for Tonic"Great at movements"4
LeoThe undead ChurchAn older cat used for "quiet staring"; he did the bird-eating scene4
JDBackup for LeoOnce abandoned in an apartment for a month4

What happens to Church in Pet Sematary?

Church is killed on the road in front of the Creeds' house, and Louis buries him in an old Mi'kmaq burial ground, deeper in the woods than the children's pet cemetery.19 He comes back, but he "acts, feels, and smells a bit off."9 King's character list also names Quentin L. Jolander, the vet who neutered Church.1

Was Church based on a real cat?

Yes, on Smucky.9 In early 1979 King was renting a house in Orrington, Maine, on a busy truck route, and his daughter's cat was killed by a truck. He buried the cat in a pet cemetery local children had made in the woods; the idea for the novel came three days later.1 His daughter Naomi marked the grave with a cross saying Smucky "was obedient."10 In the novel, a cat named Smucky lies in the pet cemetery.1

Mix-ups and myths

"Seven cats played Church in 1989." Cinema Cats says he "was reportedly played by seven different cats."11 Lambert's own count is "eight or nine cats."6

"Eight cats played Church in 2019." That is Widmyer's figure from a premiere Q&A.5 The trainers told Inverse that five cats were recruited and four are credited.4 I found no credit list that settles it.

"The 2019 cats were purebred Maine Coons." SyFy Wire calls Leo "one of four Maine Coons,"8 but Time calls him a "Maine Coon crossbreed,"7 and all five recruits came from shelters.4 With no pedigree shown, "Maine Coon-type" is the safer label.

Church quiz: 5 questions

  1. What is Church's full name?

    Answer

    Winston Churchill.1

  2. How old is Church in the novel?

    Answer

    Five.1

  3. Which real cat's death inspired the novel?

    Answer

    Smucky.9

  4. Which cat played the undead Church in 2019?

    Answer

    Leo, with JD as his backup.4

  5. What did the 2019 directors base the cats' look on?

    Answer

    The original drawing of Church from the first hardcover edition.2

More questions about famous cats are in the Cat Trivia game, free to play with no account.

Frequently asked questions

Is Church a boy or a girl?

A boy. Bicks calls him "he" in her summary of the novel,9 King's site lists the vet who neutered him,1 and the 2019 trainers call each credited cat "he."4

What happened to Leo, the 2019 Church?

He died weeks after the film's debut, Time reported on May 30, 2019; Jarrett announced it on Instagram without giving a cause.7

Christopher Fox, creator of Cat Trivia Games
Christopher Fox
Creator of Cat Trivia Games

Christopher writes and runs Cat Trivia Games. The sources for this article are listed below, and how the site is made and corrected is on the editorial policy page. More about the author.

References

  1. Stephen King, official site. Pet Sematary: release, publisher, inspiration and characters. back
  2. American Humane (April 1, 2019; archived copy, the original link no longer loads). American Humane on the set of Pet Sematary, with director Dennis Widmyer. back
  3. Box Office Mojo. Pet Sematary (1989): distributor and release date and credits. back
  4. Corey Plante, Inverse (April 22, 2019). Pet Sematary: here's how they wrangled 4 cats to play Church. back
  5. Hoai-Tran Bui, SlashFilm (April 5, 2019), quoting Dennis Widmyer as reported by Entertainment Weekly. The eight cats who played Church in Pet Sematary were "a pack of divas." back
  6. Jacob Simmons, Far Out Magazine (November 23, 2024), quoting Mary Lambert's interview with The Hollywood Reporter. The Stephen King movie that sedated a cat. back
  7. Madeline Fitzgerald, Time (May 30, 2019). Pet Sematary movie's breakout star Leo the cat dies. back
  8. Josh Weiss, SyFy Wire (May 30, 2019). Leo the cat, who played undead Church in Pet Sematary remake, has died. back
  9. Caroline Bicks, Lit Hub (April 22, 2026), excerpt from Monsters in the Archives (Hogarth). Discoveries reading the first draft of Stephen King's Pet Sematary. back
  10. Meagan Bojarski, Mental Floss (October 14, 2026). The real pet cemetery that inspired Stephen King's most personal horror novel. back
  11. Cinema Cats (December 6, 2014). Pet Sematary (1989). back

Written by Christopher Fox under our editorial policy.