9 Cat Myths Explained
Some familiar advice about cats is wrong. Some is only partly true. Here are nine claims worth a closer look, from milk and purring to the idea that cats always land safely.
Myth 1: Cats always land on their feet
The righting reflex is real. Using the balance organs in the inner ear and a flexible spine, a falling cat can twist so its feet point down, and most kittens have the reflex by about seven weeks old. It does not work every time.1
Landing on its feet is also not the same as landing safely. Cats that fall from the second story or higher often arrive at the vet with chest injuries, shock, injuries to the head and face, and broken legs, a pattern vets call high-rise syndrome. The term came from veterinarians in New York City in the 1980s, who saw many cats survive long falls.2 Studies like that can only count cats that reached a clinic, so their survival figures say nothing about cats that never made it there.
Keep windows and balconies secure. A cat's righting reflex does not make a fall safe. A cat that has fallen from a height should see a vet right away, even if it seems fine, because some injuries, such as bruised lungs, can get worse over the next two days.2
Myth 2: All cats hate water
Plenty of cats dislike getting wet, but the dislike is not universal. The Cat Fanciers' Association describes the Turkish Van as well known for its affinity to water, and the Bengal as fascinated by water, sometimes to the point of trying to join you in the shower.34 Some cats also prefer drinking from running water.5 A breed tendency does not promise how one cat will feel about a bath, so let yours show you.
Myth 3: Milk is good for cats
Many adult cats have difficulty digesting lactose and can develop digestive problems if fed dairy products.6
Kittens digest their mother's milk, but as they wean, usually around eight weeks, many lose much of the enzyme that breaks lactose down. Undigested lactose draws water into the gut and can cause diarrhea, gas and vomiting.7 Cornell's Feline Health Center does not generally recommend milk as a treat for that reason.6 Fresh water is the drink cats need.
Myth 4: A purring cat is always a happy cat
Cats purr when content, but also when anxious, at the vet, and when sick or in pain.8 Pain in cats can be hard to spot. International Cat Care notes that the belief that cats feel less pain than dogs may largely reflect the two species behaving differently when hurt, rather than a real difference in what they feel.9 Read the purr together with the rest of the cat: posture, ears, eating and activity. The purring guide goes into what the sound can mean.
Myth 5: Cats are aloof and do not bond with people
In a 2019 Oregon State University study, cats took a test adapted from research on human infants: a short time in a new room with their caregiver, a short time alone, then a reunion. About 64 percent of 70 kittens and 66 percent of 38 adult cats were classed as securely attached, close to the 65 percent seen in human infants.10 In an earlier study from the same lab, most of the cats tested preferred interacting with a person over food, toys or scents, though individual cats varied.11
Those results describe groups of cats under test conditions. They do not tell you what a particular cat feels. Cats also direct most of their meows at people rather than at other cats, which International Cat Care puts down partly to people rewarding the meow.12 If you want to understand your own cat's habits, the guide to why cats follow people around is a good place to start.
Myth 6: Black cats are bad luck
Black is a coat color. In European folklore, black cats are tied to both good and bad luck, and in Britain and Ireland a black cat crossing your path is often considered a good omen.13
A related claim is that black cats are the least likely to be adopted from shelters. That is widely debated, and studies have reached conflicting results.13 Adoption figures depend on the shelter, the place, the period and how adoption is measured, so one sweeping answer would claim more than the evidence shows.
Myth 7: Cats have nine lives
A cat has one life. The number of lives in the saying also changes with the country: nine in many places, seven in Italy, Germany, Greece, Brazil and some Spanish-speaking regions, and six in Arabic traditions. An early written mention of the nine-lives idea comes from John Heywood's book of proverbs in 1546. The myth is usually put down to how nimbly cats get out of dangerous situations.14
Myth 8: Indoor cats do not need vaccines
Cornell's Feline Health Center reports that the American Association of Feline Practitioners' vaccination panel recommends core vaccines for all household cats, including those kept indoors at all times: panleukopenia, feline herpesvirus, calicivirus and rabies.15 The AVMA notes that many state and local laws require certain vaccinations even for indoor-only pets, and the ASPCA says rabies vaccination is the law in many areas.1617 Your vet can tell you which other vaccines suit your cat's lifestyle.
Myth 9: Cats can see in complete darkness
Cats see about six times better than people in dim light, which is where this myth comes from, but they still need some light.18 A reflective layer behind the retina, the tapetum lucidum, gives some light a second chance to be absorbed, and it is also why cat eyes shine in photos. In a room with no light at all, a cat has to rely on other senses, such as its whiskers. The full explanation is in Can Cats See in the Dark?
Key takeaways
- Keep windows and balconies secure; the righting reflex does not make falls safe.
- Skip the saucer of milk. Fresh water is what cats need.
- A purr is not proof of comfort. Look at the whole cat.
- Indoor cats still need core vaccines; ask your vet about the rest.
Frequently asked questions
Can kittens drink cow's milk?
No. PetMD advises that kittens should only have their mother's milk or a milk replacer made for kittens, not milk from cows, goats or sheep.
Do overweight cats land on their feet as well as lean cats?
VCA notes that overweight cats are much less likely to be able to right themselves during a fall. Another reason to keep windows secure.
Which vaccines depend on lifestyle?
Beyond the core vaccines, Cornell explains that the choice of other vaccines depends on a cat's lifestyle, age, health and contact with other cats. Feline leukemia vaccination is considered core for cats under one year old.
References
- VCA Animal Hospitals. True or false: cats always land on their feet. back
- PetMD. High-rise syndrome in cats. back
- The Cat Fanciers' Association. Turkish Van. back
- The Cat Fanciers' Association. Bengal. back
- International Cat Care. Why do cats..? (drinking from the tap). back
- Cornell Feline Health Center. Feeding your cat. back
- PetMD. Can cats drink milk? back
- Sung, W., DVM, DACVB, PetMD. Why do cats purr? 5 meanings behind a purring cat. back
- International Cat Care. Cats deserve pain relief too. back
- Oregon State University (2019), on Vitale, K. R. et al., Current Biology. Cats, like children and dogs, develop attachments to their caregivers, study shows. back
- Vitale Shreve, K. R. et al., Behavioural Processes (2017). Social interaction, food, scent or toys? A formal assessment of domestic pet and shelter cat preferences. back
- International Cat Care. Cat communication. back
- Wikipedia. Black cat (folklore, adoption rates). back
- Wikipedia. Cat (the "nine lives" myth). back
- Cornell Feline Health Center. Feline vaccines: benefits and risks. back
- American Veterinary Medical Association. Vaccinating your pet. back
- ASPCA. Common cat diseases (rabies). back
- Merck Veterinary Manual. Eye structure and function in cats. back
This is general information, not veterinary advice. Written by Christopher Fox under our editorial policy.
